Compare Your Company Stock to a Leveraged Index Fund
Say you work at a private company that gives you stock options or RSUs. How should you value your stock?
- If you have a choice between getting more stock or more cash salary, how do you decide which to get?
- If you have the chance to sell some stock, should you do it?
Stock is risky and inflexible (especially if you work for a private company where you can’t easily sell shares), but you might be able to get it at a discount to its true value. How do you estimate how much it’s worth?
One heuristic you can use is to compare the stock against a risk-matched index fund. What would happen if you used the cash to buy a leveraged index fund with the same level of risk as the company stock? If the leveraged index fund has a higher expected return than the company stock, that means cash is probably better. (The reverse is not necessarily true because company stock can have other downsides, which I will get into later.)
Continue reading
